Reviews

Proton Pass Review: Strong Free Plan, Newer Record

A strong, privacy-focused password manager with a useful free plan and a recent outside audit. It is newer than rivals, and reviews disagree on how reliable its autofill is.

8.3/10

ChainMatch score · Password managers

Research-based Method v1.1 · scored November 10, 2026

CriterionWeightScoreWhy
Security design 30% 8.5 Proton says your vault is encrypted on your device before it reaches Proton's servers. It says every Proton Pass app is open source, so anyone can read the code. The outside firm Recurity Labs tested the apps in early 2026 and Proton published the report, which we read on November 10, 2026. It rates the security 'well above par'. Its table lists eight findings, none rated high or critical. The one medium finding was closed at the retest. We took off 1.5 points. Seven findings were still open at the retest: six rated low and one with no rating. Proton chose not to fix usernames stored unscrambled on Android and held back an iPhone fix. The testers also call their code review 'necessarily cursory' and checked Proton's servers only from the outside. Proton's own design notes warn that shared vaults could be fooled by fake encryption keys. We found no published research testing that risk. The 2026 ETH Zurich study of attacks from hacked servers did not include Proton Pass.
Account protection 20% 8.0 Free and paid accounts can add an authenticator app or up to four hardware security keys as a second login step. Paid plans add emergency access for up to five trusted people. You choose whether they get in at once or after a wait, and you can say no during the wait. We couldn't confirm that you can sign in to your Proton account with a passkey. Storing passkeys for other sites in Proton Pass is a different feature.
Track record 20% 8.5 We found no breach of customer vaults since Proton Pass launched in 2023. Two flaws found by researchers were fixed. A 2023 bug that left passwords in memory after locking was fixed within days. A 2025 autofill trick called clickjacking (hidden clicks) worked on 11 password managers. Proton says version 1.31.6 fixed it, and no attacks on customers were reported. The two CVE records on Proton's advisories page concern other Proton products. We took off 1.5 points. Proton Pass has under five years of history. Proton also disputes a January 2025 claim that card numbers could be read from its Windows app's memory. It hasn't announced a fix.
Ease of use 15% 7.5 There are apps for Windows, Mac, Linux, iPhone and Android, plus a web app and five browser extensions. A family plan covers up to six people, and reviewers call the design clean. But reviews disagree about autofill, which fills in your logins for you. One review says it isn't always reliable on multi-step logins, some websites and phones.
Value 15% 9.0 The free plan covers unlimited passwords and devices, the browser, phone and computer apps, passkeys, security-key login and 10 email aliases. It limits you to 2 vaults and sharing with 2 people. On November 10, 2026 Proton's pricing page showed Pass Plus at $1.99 a month, billed $23.88 for the first 12 months. It then renews at $35.88 every 12 months, about 1.8 times Bitwarden Premium's $19.80 a year. The page doesn't say when the first-year offer ends.

How we score password managers

Good

  • The free plan has unlimited logins and devices, apps for browsers, phones and computers, passkey support and 10 email aliases, with no credit card needed (Proton's pricing page, checked November 10, 2026).
  • Recurity Labs audited the apps between January and April 2026. Their report rates the security 'well above par' and lists no high or critical finding. The one medium finding was closed at the retest.
  • Proton says all Proton Pass apps are open source. GitHub shows public GPL-3.0 code for the Android and iPhone apps and a command-line tool (a text-only app for technical users). Proton's web clients code includes the Pass web app, browser extension and desktop app.
  • Free and paid Proton accounts can add an authenticator app or up to four hardware security keys as a second login step, according to Proton's documentation.
  • Paid plans add emergency access: up to five trusted contacts, with a wait time you choose and a chance to say no during it.
  • Apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iPhone, a web app, five browser extensions and a command-line tool. Pass Family covers up to six people.
  • We found no report of a breach of customer vaults since launch in 2023. Proton says it fixed a 2023 memory bug within days and a 2025 clickjacking flaw in version 1.31.6.

Watch out for

  • Proton Pass launched in 2023, so its record is short. CyberInsider's review lists being newer than established competitors as a downside.
  • The February 2026 ETH Zurich and USI study of password managers with a hacked server did not include Proton Pass, and we found no outside test of that threat. Proton's own notes say vault sharing carries a risk of fake encryption keys.
  • Seven audit findings were still open at the retest: six rated low and one with no rating. They include usernames stored unscrambled on Android, which Proton won't fix, and an iPhone fix Proton held back.
  • Proton disputes, rather than fixes, a January 2025 claim that card numbers could be read from the Windows app's memory by an attacker already on the computer.
  • Built-in authenticator codes, emergency access, secure links and folders need a paid plan. Pass Plus is $23.88 for the first year, then renews at $35.88 a year (checked November 10, 2026), against $19.80 a year for Bitwarden Premium.
  • Reviews disagree on autofill, Experte says support is a contact form only, and the reviews we found come from sites that earn commissions.
  • We couldn't confirm security-key sign-in in the phone and desktop apps, passkey sign-in to a Proton account, or what happens if you forget your account password.

Best for: The Privacy-First User. Find your profile.

Who it’s for

Proton Pass is a password manager: an app that creates a strong, different password for every account and remembers them for you. It suits The Privacy-First User, who wants code anyone can read, a vault locked on their own device and a company that publishes its audits.

It is a weaker fit if you want a long track record, a live support line or the cheapest paid plan. We haven’t listed it for The Newcomer. The ease-of-use reviews we found come from sites that earn commissions, and they disagree about autofill (the feature that fills in your logins for you). The free plan lets anyone try it.

This is a research-based review. It rests on Proton’s documentation, its public code, outside auditors’ and researchers’ reports and news coverage. See how we score password managers.

What you get and what it costs

According to Proton’s pricing page (checked November 10, 2026), there are three Pass plans. The paid prices below are for paying yearly.

  • Free, $0, no credit card. Unlimited logins, notes, cards and devices, passkey support, weak and reused password alerts and 10 hide-my-email aliases (addresses that forward email to your inbox and keep your real one hidden). The limits are 2 vaults and sharing with 2 other people.
  • Pass Plus, $23.88 for the first 12 months, then $35.88 a year. The page shows $1.99 a month beside a crossed-out $4.99. It adds a built-in authenticator (a feature that makes one-time login codes), unlimited aliases, secure link sharing, folders and emergency access.
  • Pass Family, $33.48 for the first 12 months, then $59.88 a year. Up to six users, each with Pass Plus, plus an admin panel.

The page says each lower price is for the first 12 months and gives the price the plan renews at. It doesn’t say when the offer ends, so check the price at checkout. It offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, but the FAQ names Pass Plus and Proton Unlimited, not Pass Family. The command-line tool (a text-only app for technical users) and file attachments need a paid plan.

For comparison, Bitwarden Premium is $19.80 a year, according to Bitwarden’s pricing page (checked November 10, 2026).

Proton’s download page lists apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iPhone, a web app, a command-line tool and extensions for Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Edge and Brave.

How it keeps you safe

  • Your vault is locked on your device. Your vault is the encrypted store of your saved logins. Proton’s security page says items use 256-bit AES-GCM encryption (a widely used standard) with a random key for each vault. It adds that “your data is never accessible to us and only you can decrypt it using your secret password.” Security people call this design zero-knowledge: the company can’t read what you save.
  • Keys are layered. Proton’s 2023 design post says each item has its own key, locked by the vault key, which is locked by a user key. For accounts with one password, the user key is protected by a bcrypt hash (a slow scrambling step) of your account password. These are Proton’s claims, and we found no independent test of them.
  • The code is public. Open source means anyone can read and check the code. Proton says all Pass apps are open source. GitHub shows code under the GPL-3.0 open-source licence for the Android, iPhone and command-line apps. Proton’s web clients repository, also GPL-3.0, holds folders for the Pass web app, browser extension and desktop app.
  • A recent outside audit. Proton’s post of May 12, 2026 says Recurity Labs, a consultancy with no financial ties to Proton, audited the browser extensions, mobile and desktop apps and command-line tool between January and April 2026. Proton says Recurity found no remote exploits and no encryption bypasses. The report itself, which we read on November 10, 2026, rates the security posture “well above par”. Its table lists eight findings, none rated high or critical. See “What the 2026 audit found” below for the ones still open.
  • An older audit. Cure53, an outside security firm, audited the mobile apps, browser extensions and the servers the apps talk to (the API) in May and June 2023. Proton published the results on July 19, 2023. Cure53 described “a moderate number of findings and most security vulnerabilities limited in severity.” Proton says all were resolved except one medium item it can’t fix because of an Android limit.
  • A second login step, free. You sign in to Pass with a Proton Account. Proton’s support pages say free and paid accounts can add an authenticator app or a physical security key (a USB or tap device that proves it’s you). You can add up to four keys, set up on the web. Proton’s Pass pages don’t describe two-factor login, so this rests on the account pages.
  • Passkeys. A passkey is a login that uses a key stored on your device instead of a typed password. Proton’s passkey guide says they work in the browser extension, on Android 14 or later and on iOS 17 or later. The guide is undated and doesn’t mention the web or desktop apps. Proton’s product page says passkeys are supported “on all devices”, which looks broader.
  • Emergency access, on paid plans. Announced August 28, 2025, it lets you name up to five trusted contacts. They get access at once or after a wait you set, from days to months. During the wait you can approve or deny the request. If you do nothing, it is approved when the wait ends. It covers your whole Proton account, not only Pass.
  • A way for researchers to report flaws. Proton’s disclosure policy lists Pass in scope and promises to acknowledge reports within five business days. Its bug bounty page lists rewards up to $100,000 but doesn’t name Pass.

Where it falls short

We found no report of a breach of customer vaults since Pass launched in 2023. Proton’s advisories page lists two security advisories without product names. The CVE records (public entries that list known security flaws) show that one concerns Standard Notes, a different Proton product, and the other, from July 2024, concerns Proton VPN for Windows. Neither names Proton Pass.

Our method can limit a grade after a serious incident or an unfixed problem that puts customers at risk. No limit applies here. The 2025 clickjacking flaw and the 2023 memory bug were fixed, with no reported attacks on customers. The audit items still open are rated low, apart from one with no rating. That one is browser autofill that matches across subdomains of a site, which the auditors also call “a common UX tradeoff”. Reading the Android usernames needs full control of the phone, according to CyberInsider. The disputed card-number claim needs a program already running on your computer that reads the app’s memory. Venak Security, which made the claim, didn’t say whether Pass was locked at the time.

It is newer than its rivals. According to Wikipedia, the paid beta began on April 20, 2023 and the global launch was June 28, 2023. That is under five years of history. CyberInsider’s review lists being newer than established competitors as a downside.

August 2025: autofill clickjacking. Clickjacking is a trick that makes you click something other than what you think you’re clicking. The Hacker News reported on August 20, 2025 that researcher Marek Tóth tested 11 password manager extensions and all were susceptible. It didn’t name Proton Pass. Proton’s post of November 12, 2025 says his talk used Proton Pass as an example and that he carried out the attack on its browser app.

Proton says version 1.31.6 fixed it and that the browser app is “no longer vulnerable to reported clickjacking attacks.” It reports no attacks in the wild and gives no release date for 1.31.6. Proton’s public code on GitHub shows the change notes for versions 1.31.5 and 1.31.6 were added on June 5, 2025, two months before the talk. Those notes don’t mention clickjacking. CyberInsider said on the same day that Proton Pass was one of a few vendors that had released a fix. Wikipedia says that, according to Tóth, version 1.31.6 addressed the issue. We couldn’t open Tóth’s own write-up, and we found no independent retest of the fix. Proton suggests automatic updates and says you could turn off manual autofill and use copy and paste.

September 2023: data left in memory. Memory is a device’s short-term working space. CyberInsider reported on September 19, 2023 that Mike Kuketz, a penetration tester (a security expert paid to find weaknesses), found Proton Pass kept decrypted data in memory for about 30 minutes after the PIN lock. Proton said the bug, found earlier in the Cure53 audit, “has been reintroduced recently.” It called an attack “a highly unlikely scenario” and released a fix on all platforms within days. No exploitation was reported.

January 2025: a disputed claim about card numbers. Venak Security said on January 27, 2025 that someone who can read the Windows app’s memory could extract stored card numbers. Proton says an admin account is needed for that, which Venak disputed. A Proton support page calls the claims “without merit.” It says data you are viewing “must be stored unencrypted in memory” and that “This is how every password manager works and is not a bug.” It says Pass keeps sensitive data encrypted on disk and obfuscated in memory while idle. We found no fix announced and no report of customers harmed. We can’t say who is right.

What the 2026 audit found. We read the Recurity Labs report on November 10, 2026. The testers had the source code for the command-line tool, the desktop and mobile apps and the browser extensions, and they tested against Proton’s live service. The report calls the work “time-boxed and best-effort” and says its code review “is necessarily cursory”. Proton’s servers were checked only from the outside, with no source code and no access to the systems.

The report’s table lists eight findings. None is rated high or critical. The one medium finding was on Android, where user data wasn’t removed consistently. It was closed at the retest, though the testers note “a potential gap” they describe as minor and time-limited. IT-Connect says Android needs version 1.39.2 or later.

Seven findings were still open at the retest. Six are rated low and one has no rating.

  • Command-line tool, four low findings. They cover file links that aren’t checked, loose permissions on files that hold session tokens, and two timing flaws. The report says Proton’s patches addressed the flaws but “are technically not fully complete” and leave “a very small residual window”.
  • Android, one low finding. The username appears unscrambled in the phone’s storage. Proton told the testers it won’t fix this because it falls outside its threat model (the attacks a product is built to stop). CyberInsider says reading it needs root access (full control of the phone).
  • iPhone, one low finding. The app uses a weak protection setting in the iPhone’s built-in password store (Keychain). Proton said a fix exists but wouldn’t ship yet because it is “a high-risk change”, and asked for the iPhone app to be left out of the retest.
  • Browser extensions, one finding with no rating. Autofill still matches across subdomains of a site, such as mail.example.com and shop.example.com. The report says this may leak logins on subdomains. It calls it a vulnerability and also “a common UX tradeoff” (a trade-off made to keep the app easy to use).

The report adds that Proton fixed many unrated notes about how secrets are handled in memory, which were first judged outside its threat model. CyberInsider notes that the audit “does not guarantee the absence of vulnerabilities.”

We found no outside test of hacked-server attacks. In February 2026, researchers at ETH Zurich and USI studied what happens if a password manager’s servers are hacked or malicious. The paper’s abstract names Bitwarden, LastPass, Dashlane and 1Password, and Help Net Security lists the same four. Proton Pass wasn’t part of it.

A Secrets of Privacy article of August 5, 2026 says Proton Pass’s absence from the study is “not the same as giving Proton Pass a passing grade.” Proton’s 2023 post claims that even a malicious Proton can’t reveal password-equivalent information. The same post warns that sharing creates a risk of fake public keys (encryption keys an attacker swaps in). It describes one check, a signature the recipient verifies. We found no outside test of whether a hacked server could exploit this. That, and the open audit items, are why its security design isn’t scored higher.

Autofill and support. Experte (updated March 24, 2026) calls autofill “decent, but not always reliable,” and says it can struggle with multi-step logins, some websites and mobile use. It says support is a contact form with slow replies and no live chat or phone line. CyberInsider says autofill works reliably across major browsers and apps, and also lists no live chat and import or export that can need manual steps.

Digital Trends (August 6, 2024) found autofill worked, but the reviewer had to enter the master password more often than they wanted. Turning on Windows Hello needed two-factor login first. Its list of missing features is out of date, because Proton added a family plan in October 2024. All three sites disclose commissions or affiliate links. We didn’t open an independent review from a site without them.

What we couldn’t confirm. Proton’s 2022 security keys post said keys worked on the web only, with apps planned. A newer undated page says to sign in from any Proton app, so current app coverage is unclear. We also couldn’t confirm that you can sign in to a Proton Account with a passkey. We didn’t research how account recovery works if you forget your password.

Setting it up safely

  • Get Proton Pass only from Proton’s official site. Type proton.me/pass yourself, then follow its links to your app store or browser extension store. Don’t use a link from an email, ad or message.
  • Choose a long account password you use nowhere else. For accounts with one password, Proton says your vault keys are protected using it. We didn’t research what happens if you forget it, so read Proton’s account recovery help before you move all your logins in.
  • Turn on a second login step. Use an authenticator app, a security key or both. Proton says that if you lose a key and have no authenticator app, you need a 2FA recovery code (a one-time backup code you save when you turn on two-factor login) or another recovery method, so save your codes somewhere safe.
  • Keep apps and extensions updated. Proton recommends automatic updates.
  • Keep your recovery phrase out of the vault. A recovery phrase is the 12 or 24 words that unlock a crypto wallet, also called a seed phrase. As in our 60-second scam check, write it on paper or metal and keep it offline. We found nothing about how Proton Pass treats recovery phrases. Use it for exchange, email and bank logins. For larger amounts, see our Trezor Safe 3 review on hardware wallets.
  • Start on the free plan. It covers core use. If you pay for Plus, you have 30 days to ask for a refund, according to Proton.

If you think someone got into one of your accounts, change its password from a device you trust. In the US, report it to the FBI at ic3.gov and the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov. Elsewhere, use your national fraud service. Ignore anyone who offers to recover stolen funds for a fee.

Alternatives

Bitwarden is the closest comparison. According to its documentation, the free plan has unlimited storage of logins and access on any device, and sharing with one other person. Premium is $19.80 a year. Our Bitwarden review covers a 2026 incident in its command-line tool and researcher findings about hacked-server attacks, with one fix still in progress. Pick it if you want the lower paid price or an audit list with an assessment in every year from 2020 to 2025, and the open issues don’t bother you.

1Password has no free plan, only a 14-day trial. Individual is $3.99 a month billed yearly, or $2.99 a month for the first year for new customers who buy directly, according to 1Password’s pricing page (checked November 10, 2026). Our 1Password review explains that 1Password says its August 2025 clickjacking issue has no complete fix. Proton says it fixed its own. Pick 1Password if you prefer its Secret Key design (an extra code on top of your password) and don’t mind paying.

Not sure which setup fits you? Use the setup finder.

Buy only from the official site. Scammers sell tampered devices on marketplaces and run lookalike stores.

Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method.

Compare Proton Pass with

Bitwarden1Password

Sources

  1. Proton Pass: Pricing (checked November 10, 2026)
  2. Proton Pass: Product page
  3. Proton Pass: Download
  4. Proton Pass: Security
  5. Proton: Proton Pass security model (April 20, 2023)
  6. Proton: Open source and Cure53 audit (July 19, 2023)
  7. Proton: Recurity Labs audit of Proton Pass (May 12, 2026)
  8. Recurity Labs: Proton Pass, Security Assessment & Retests (report, read November 10, 2026)
  9. CyberInsider: Proton Pass rated well above par in audit (May 13, 2026)
  10. IT-Connect: Proton Pass audit findings (May 13, 2026)
  11. Proton: Use passkeys in Proton Pass
  12. Proton: Two-factor authentication
  13. Proton: Security keys for 2FA
  14. Proton: Security keys announcement (October 13, 2022)
  15. Proton: Emergency Access (August 28, 2025)
  16. GitHub: Proton Pass organisation
  17. GitHub: ProtonMail WebClients
  18. GitHub: ProtonMail WebClients applications folder
  19. GitHub: Proton Pass desktop app code
  20. Proton: Clickjacking and Proton Pass (November 12, 2025)
  21. The Hacker News: DOM-based extension clickjacking (August 20, 2025)
  22. CyberInsider: Proton Pass patches clickjacking vulnerability (November 12, 2025)
  23. GitHub: Proton Pass 1.31.5 and 1.31.6 changelog commit (June 5, 2025)
  24. CyberInsider: Proton Pass keeps passwords in memory (September 19, 2023)
  25. Venak Security: Memory protection claims (January 27, 2025)
  26. Proton: Response to Venak claims
  27. Proton: Security advisories
  28. CVE record: CVE-2026-78325
  29. CVE record: CVE-2024-37391
  30. Proton: Vulnerability disclosure policy
  31. Proton: Bug bounty
  32. IACR ePrint 2026/058: Password manager attacks from a malicious server
  33. Help Net Security: Password manager weaknesses (February 17, 2026)
  34. Secrets of Privacy: Zero-knowledge password managers and server-side attacks (August 5, 2026)
  35. Experte: Proton Pass review (updated March 24, 2026)
  36. CyberInsider: Proton Pass review (August 25, 2026)
  37. Digital Trends: Proton Pass review (August 6, 2024)
  38. Wikipedia: Proton Pass (launch history)
  39. Bitwarden: Pricing (checked November 10, 2026)
  40. Bitwarden: Password Manager plans
  41. Bitwarden: Is Bitwarden audited?
  42. 1Password: Pricing (checked November 10, 2026)