Compare products · Password managers
Proton Pass vs 1Password
Proton Pass scores 8.3 out of 10 and 1Password scores 4.0 by our method.
What the scores say
- Proton Pass scores higher on security design, account protection, track record and value.
- 1Password scores higher on ease of use.
- 1Password has an unfixed security problem, which holds its score at 4.0. Its criteria alone would give 6.8.
A higher score doesn't make a product right for you. The setup finder matches password managers to how you'll use crypto.
| Measure | Proton PassProtonRead reviewVisit Proton | 1Password1PasswordRead reviewVisit 1Password |
|---|---|---|
| Scores | ||
| ChainMatch score0 to 10, from the criteria below. How we score | 8.3 | 4.0 |
| Security design30% of the score. | 8.5WhyProton says your vault is encrypted on your device before it reaches Proton's servers. It says every Proton Pass app is open source, so anyone can read the code. The outside firm Recurity Labs tested the apps in early 2026 and Proton published the report, which we read on November 10, 2026. It rates the security 'well above par'. Its table lists eight findings, none rated high or critical. The one medium finding was closed at the retest. We took off 1.5 points. Seven findings were still open at the retest: six rated low and one with no rating. Proton chose not to fix usernames stored unscrambled on Android and held back an iPhone fix. The testers also call their code review 'necessarily cursory' and checked Proton's servers only from the outside. Proton's own design notes warn that shared vaults could be fooled by fake encryption keys. We found no published research testing that risk. The 2026 ETH Zurich study of attacks from hacked servers did not include Proton Pass. | 6.5WhyYour vault is encrypted on your device with your password plus a 128-bit Secret Key that 1Password never holds, but the code isn't open source, the only audit reports posted publicly are from 2020 or carry no date (newer pen-test reports sit in a Trust Center that shows no dates or auditors), and in 2026 university researchers described three ways a hacked 1Password server could attack vaults, limits 1Password says it already documented and hasn't fixed yet. Those attacks only work after someone takes over 1Password's servers, and we found no report of them being used against customers, so they lower this score but are not the reason for our cap on the overall grade. |
| Account protection20% of the score. | 8.0WhyFree and paid accounts can add an authenticator app or up to four hardware security keys as a second login step. Paid plans add emergency access for up to five trusted people. You choose whether they get in at once or after a wait, and you can say no during the wait. We couldn't confirm that you can sign in to your Proton account with a passkey. Storing passkeys for other sites in Proton Pass is a different feature. | 7.0WhyOn top of your password and Secret Key you can require a hardware security key (the older U2F type) or an authenticator app, but unlocking with a passkey is only a beta for new accounts, and there's no built-in emergency access, only workarounds such as giving someone a recovery code or your Emergency Kit. |
| Track record20% of the score. | 8.5WhyWe found no breach of customer vaults since Proton Pass launched in 2023. Two flaws found by researchers were fixed. A 2023 bug that left passwords in memory after locking was fixed within days. A 2025 autofill trick called clickjacking (hidden clicks) worked on 11 password managers. Proton says version 1.31.6 fixed it, and no attacks on customers were reported. The two CVE records on Proton's advisories page concern other Proton products. We took off 1.5 points. Proton Pass has under five years of history. Proton also disputes a January 2025 claim that card numbers could be read from its Windows app's memory. It hasn't announced a fix. | 8.0WhyWe found no breach of customer vaults in the past five years, and 1Password posts dated security advisories, including for a 2023 break-in through its Okta login system that it stopped with no user data taken, but it still hasn't fully fixed a 2025 autofill trick that can leak your saved personal details. |
| Ease of use15% of the score. | 7.5WhyThere are apps for Windows, Mac, Linux, iPhone and Android, plus a web app and five browser extensions. A family plan covers up to six people, and reviewers call the design clean. But reviews disagree about autofill, which fills in your logins for you. One review says it isn't always reliable on multi-step logins, some websites and phones. | 8.0WhyThere are apps for Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone, Android and the main browsers, and the family plan makes sharing simple, but CyberInsider's review found it sometimes misses saving new logins and said the Secret Key can confuse beginners. |
| Value15% of the score. | 9.0WhyThe free plan covers unlimited passwords and devices, the browser, phone and computer apps, passkeys, security-key login and 10 email aliases. It limits you to 2 vaults and sharing with 2 people. On November 10, 2026 Proton's pricing page showed Pass Plus at $1.99 a month, billed $23.88 for the first 12 months. It then renews at $35.88 every 12 months, about 1.8 times Bitwarden Premium's $19.80 a year. The page doesn't say when the first-year offer ends. | 4.5WhyThere's no free plan, only a 14-day trial, and 1Password's terms say payments are non-refundable. The Individual plan costs $3.99 a month billed yearly ($2.99 in the first year for new customers), more than twice Bitwarden Premium's $1.65, though there's no stripped-down tier and the family plan covers five people for $5.99 a month. |
| Serious security problemsAn unfixed problem limits the score to 4.0. A flaw in the product itself that has cost customers money, with users still at risk, limits it to 0.0. A serious incident in the last 24 months that has been fixed limits it to 8.0. Older ones are in the review. How we score | None in the last 24 months | Unfixed problem |
| Details | ||
| SetupHow much experience it takes to set up. | Beginner-friendly | Beginner-friendly |
| How we checked itHands-on means a person on our team used it. | Research | Research |
| Last scoredWhen we last scored it. | Nov 2026 | Nov 2026 |
| Features | ||
| Open source | Yes | Not confirmed |
| Passkeys | Yes | Yes |
| Phone app | Yes | Yes |
| Desktop app | Yes | Yes |
| Free plan | Yes | Not confirmed |
| Family plan | Yes | Yes |
Highlighted cells are the better of the two. Scores: 7–10 4–6.9 0–3.9
We list a feature only when a source confirms it. "Not confirmed" means we haven't found one, not that the feature is missing. Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method. How we score password managers.