How we score · version 1.1
How we score password managers
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Security design | 30% |
| Account protection | 20% |
| Track record | 20% |
| Ease of use | 15% |
| Value | 15% |
Most crypto account takeovers start with a reused or stolen password. A password manager creates a unique, strong password for every account and remembers it for you.
Security design
- 10: Encrypts your vault on your device so the company can’t read it (“zero-knowledge”). Recent published independent audits. Open source or audited code.
- 5: Zero-knowledge, but audits are old or limited.
- 0: The company can read your passwords, or no independent audits.
Account protection
- 10: Supports passkeys and hardware security keys for logging in, plus a safe emergency-access option.
- 5: App-based two-factor login only.
- 0: Password-only login.
Track record
- 10: No breach of customer vaults in five years, with fast, open disclosure.
- 5: A past incident, disclosed openly and fixed.
- 0: A vault breach handled slowly or hidden.
The security caps apply on top of this score.
Ease of use
- 10: Apps for every major platform, reliable autofill, easy sharing with family.
- 5: Works well on some platforms only.
- 0: Unreliable autofill or confusing setup.
Value
- 10: A useful free plan, or a paid plan among the cheapest for its features.
- 5: Average price.
- 0: Expensive, with core security features behind the top plan.