4.0/10
ChainMatch score · Password managers
Research-based Method v1.1 · scored November 10, 2026
| Criterion | Weight | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Security design | 30% | 6.5 | Your vault is encrypted on your device with your password plus a 128-bit Secret Key that 1Password never holds, but the code isn't open source, the only audit reports posted publicly are from 2020 or carry no date (newer pen-test reports sit in a Trust Center that shows no dates or auditors), and in 2026 university researchers described three ways a hacked 1Password server could attack vaults, limits 1Password says it already documented and hasn't fixed yet. Those attacks only work after someone takes over 1Password's servers, and we found no report of them being used against customers, so they lower this score but are not the reason for our cap on the overall grade. |
| Account protection | 20% | 7.0 | On top of your password and Secret Key you can require a hardware security key (the older U2F type) or an authenticator app, but unlocking with a passkey is only a beta for new accounts, and there's no built-in emergency access, only workarounds such as giving someone a recovery code or your Emergency Kit. |
| Track record | 20% | 8.0 | We found no breach of customer vaults in the past five years, and 1Password posts dated security advisories, including for a 2023 break-in through its Okta login system that it stopped with no user data taken, but it still hasn't fully fixed a 2025 autofill trick that can leak your saved personal details. |
| Ease of use | 15% | 8.0 | There are apps for Mac, Windows, Linux, iPhone, Android and the main browsers, and the family plan makes sharing simple, but CyberInsider's review found it sometimes misses saving new logins and said the Secret Key can confuse beginners. |
| Value | 15% | 4.5 | There's no free plan, only a 14-day trial, and 1Password's terms say payments are non-refundable. The Individual plan costs $3.99 a month billed yearly ($2.99 in the first year for new customers), more than twice Bitwarden Premium's $1.65, though there's no stripped-down tier and the family plan covers five people for $5.99 a month. |
Score limits that apply: an unfixed security problem (4.0 at most). How the limits work
Good
- Your vault is protected by your account password plus a 128-bit Secret Key. 1Password says it never stores the password and has no copy of the Secret Key, so it can't see what you save.
- Account login can require a security key (the FIDO U2F type, such as a YubiKey or Titan) or an authenticator app, according to 1Password's documentation.
- Apps for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android, browser extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox and Safari, and a Families plan for up to 5 members.
- 1Password keeps a dated advisory list with entries back to 2017 and gave a public account of its 2023 Okta incident. We found no report of a breach of customer vaults in the past five years.
- Several ways back in if you lose access: an Emergency Kit, recovery codes, and family-organizer recovery on Families plans.
Watch out for
- 1Password says there is no comprehensive technical fix for the August 2025 browser-extension clickjacking issue (a trick that hides what you're really clicking). It added prompts and settings and reports no active exploitation, but our method holds the grade down while the issue is open. Turning on 'Ask before filling' adds a check before autofill.
- The code isn't open source (public for anyone to read). The only independent audit reports 1Password links publicly are from 2020 (plus one undated), and newer reports need a request through its Trust Center.
- In February 2026, university researchers described three attack scenarios against 1Password if an attacker took over its servers. 1Password says they were already documented and announced no specific fix.
- No free plan, only a 14-day trial. Individual is $3.99 a month billed yearly (checked November 10, 2026), against $1.65 a month billed yearly for Bitwarden Premium, and 1Password's terms say payments are non-refundable.
- No built-in emergency access for a trusted person. Unlocking an account with a passkey is listed as a beta for new accounts.
- CyberInsider says the Secret Key setup can confuse beginners and that login capture sometimes misses entries.
Best for: The Newcomer. Find your profile.
Who it’s for
1Password is a password manager: an app that creates a strong, different password for every account and remembers them for you. It suits The Newcomer who wants one easy tool to protect exchange, email and bank logins. Reusing a password is one way scammers get into those accounts.
It is a weaker fit if you want a free plan, public code, or a built-in way for family to reach your accounts if something happens to you.
This is a research-based review. We relied on 1Password’s documentation, its published security advisories, independent reports and news coverage. See how we score password managers.
What you get and what it costs
According to 1Password, it has apps for macOS, Windows, Linux, iOS and Android, and browser extensions for Chrome, Edge, Firefox and Safari. It saves and autofills passwords, two-factor codes and addresses. Its Watchtower tool flags compromised passwords. Families plan members can share vaults, and expiring links can share items with people who don’t use 1Password.
On its pricing page (checked November 10, 2026), the Individual plan is $3.99 a month billed yearly. New customers who subscribe directly on 1Password.com see $2.99 a month for the first 12 months. Families is $5.99 a month billed yearly ($4.49 for the first year on the same terms) and covers up to 5 members.
There is no free plan. The pricing page offers a 14-day free trial and says no credit card is required.
1Password’s terms of service say you may be asked for billing details when you sign up for a trial. If you give them, you are charged on the last day of the trial unless you cancel. The terms also say payments are non-refundable, though 1Password may consider refund requests case by case.
How it keeps you safe
- Two keys protect your vault. Your vault is the encrypted store of your saved logins. According to 1Password, opening it takes your account password, which it says it never stores, plus a 128-bit Secret Key (a long extra code that 1Password keeps no copy of). The company says it can’t see what you save. Its white paper says: “We’re never in the position of learning your account password or cryptographic keys.” It adds that the Secret Key is mixed into the encryption, so stolen data can’t be used to guess your password.
- Login that sends no secrets. 1Password says it uses Secure Remote Password (SRP), a method that checks your login without sending your credentials over the internet.
- You hold the Secret Key. 1Password says it has no way to recover or reset it. You can find it on a device or browser where you’re already signed in, or in your Emergency Kit. That is a PDF with your sign-in address, email, Secret Key, a space for your password and a QR code for signing in on a phone.
- A second login step. Its two-factor page lists an authenticator app (an app that makes one-time codes) and a security key (a small device you plug in or tap). The security key page says it must be FIDO U2F-compatible, such as a YubiKey or Titan, and works only in supported apps and browsers. For other browsers, 1Password says to add an authenticator app. See our YubiKey 5C NFC review.
- Ways back in. Recovery codes work for individual and family accounts when you can’t sign in. They need access to your account’s email, and you can reuse them. On Families plans, the family organizer can start recovery for a member. The member gets a new Secret Key and password, keeps their data, and has two-factor login reset.
- Passkeys, with caveats. A passkey is a login that uses a key stored on your device instead of a typed password. 1Password can save passkeys for other sites. Its pages don’t agree on the details. The passkeys page is undated and mentions the desktop browser extension and iOS 17. The system requirements list passkey support for Windows 11 or later, iOS 18 or later and Android 14 or later, with no row for Mac or Linux. Check your device first.
Where it falls short
A 2025 autofill risk has no complete fix. Clickjacking is a trick that makes you click something other than what you think you’re clicking. On August 21, 2025, 1Password published an advisory on a version of it that targets browser extensions. It says there is no comprehensive technical fix for this kind of problem. It also says a clickjacked page could fill only one matching item per click, and that it has no reports of active exploitation.
The Hacker News reported that the researcher’s work covered 11 password manager extensions. It also reported that Socket said 1Password marked the report “informative” rather than shipping a fix. 1Password’s answer was safeguards. Version 8.11.7.2 extended “Ask before filling” confirmation prompts to identities (saved personal details), and an optional exact-domain-match setting limits where autofill appears. Our method caps a product’s overall grade while a security problem is unfixed. We applied that cap here.
The code isn’t open source, and public audits are old. Open source means anyone can read the code. A 1Password community page says it isn’t open source, though it supports open-source projects. Its security assessments page links a penetration test (a hired attempt to break in) and code review by Independent Security Evaluators from April and June 2020, and an Onica assessment with no date. It says annual penetration test reports have been available through the Trust Center since November 3, 2025. The Trust Center lists SOC 2 Type 2 and several ISO certifications (outside checks of how a company runs its security). It showed no report dates or auditor names, and the reports need an access request, so we couldn’t check them.
Researchers described attacks that need a hacked server. On February 16, 2026, researchers at ETH Zurich and USI (Università della Svizzera italiana) published a paper. It asked how password managers hold up if an attacker controls the servers that hold your encrypted vault. Help Net Security reported three attack scenarios against 1Password. 1Password’s response says two of the findings are limits it already documents in its white paper. It says the paper shows no bypass of its end-to-end encryption (scrambling that only your devices can undo), Secret Key or SRP login. It announced no specific fix and pointed to future structural work. It describes no exploitation or customer impact.
Past incidents. None of the sources we read says customer vault data was taken.
- September to October 2023, Okta. 1Password detected suspicious activity on the Okta system it uses for employee apps on September 29, 2023 and ended it immediately. On October 20 it confirmed the cause was a breach of Okta’s support system. It says it found no compromise of user data. TechTarget reported that the attacker used a file containing session cookies (data that keeps a browser signed in) to reach 1Password’s Okta admin portal. The attacker then tried to reach an IT staff member’s laptop and to get a list of all admin users. Both attempts were blocked.
- August 2024, Mac app flaw (CVE-2024-42219). A published advisory says versions before 8.10.36 let a malicious program on your Mac pose as a trusted 1Password tool, which could expose vault items. It was fixed in 8.10.36, rated Medium, and 1Password has no reports of exploitation.
- August 2024, second Mac app flaw (CVE-2024-42218). A separate advisory published the same day says malicious software already on a Mac could load an older 1Password version to get around macOS security protections. That could expose vault items. It affected 1Password 8 for Mac before 8.10.38, was fixed in 8.10.38 and was rated Medium. 1Password has no reports of anyone else finding or exploiting it.
- June 19, 2026, extension sign-in. An advisory says an extension feature trusted too many 1Password-controlled web addresses, including staging and third-party marketing ones. Extension version 8.12.21 narrows the list. It says there is no evidence of compromise and no need to change passwords or Secret Keys.
- October 28, 2026, certificate authority keys. An advisory covers compromised keys at a certificate authority (a company that vouches for websites’ identities) that 1Password calls an industry-wide issue. It affects 1Password’s self-hosted tools and its Linux app. It says 1Password.com, the browser extension and the Mac, Windows, iPhone and Android apps are not affected. It has no evidence of misuse. It said the Linux fix, version 8.12.44, was due November 3, 2026. The Linux release notes list 8.12.44 on that date but don’t mention the certificate fix, so check your version.
No built-in emergency access. In a community thread, a 1Password staff member wrote on January 24, 2024: “We do not have any available options like what you’re seeking. Well, short of sharing the Emergency Kit and password.” A pinned staff reply dated August 12, 2026 says the request “remains open”. It suggests giving a trusted person a recovery code, using your email provider’s legacy-contact feature, or storing the Emergency Kit with your will.
Passkey unlock is early. The undated passkeys page lists creating and unlocking a new Individual account with a passkey as “public beta”, and unlocking an existing account as “coming soon”. It may be out of date.
Ease of use. CyberInsider says form filling handled logins and payments well. It says login capture is less consistent and may miss some entries, and that the Secret Key setup “can confuse beginners.”
Setting it up safely
- Get 1Password only from its official site. Type 1password.com yourself, then follow its links to the app store or browser extension. Don’t use a link from an email, ad or message.
- Save your Emergency Kit. It holds your Secret Key, so treat it like a house key. 1Password suggests writing your account password on at least one printed copy. If you do, lock that copy away, because anyone who finds it can open your vault.
- Choose a long account password that you use nowhere else.
- Turn on two-factor login. Add a security key if you have one, plus an authenticator app as a backup. Save a recovery code, and protect the email account it needs.
- Turn on “Ask before filling” for sensitive item types. Consider the exact-domain-match setting for your most important logins. 1Password warns it can make autofill much harder to use on many sites.
- Keep apps and extensions updated. The advisories above name fixed versions. If you use Linux, check that you are on 8.12.44 or newer.
- Keep your recovery phrase (the 12 or 24 words that unlock a crypto wallet, also called a seed phrase) out of the vault. 1Password has a Crypto Wallet item type with a recovery phrase field. As in our 60-second scam check, we advise keeping it on paper or metal, offline. Use 1Password for exchange and email logins. For larger amounts, a hardware wallet (a small device that keeps your keys offline) is the usual choice. See our Trezor Safe 3 review.
- Practice signing in on a second device with your password and Secret Key before you need it.
If you think someone got into one of your accounts, change its password from a device you trust. In the US, report it to the FBI at ic3.gov and the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov. Elsewhere, use your national fraud service. Ignore anyone who offers to recover stolen funds for a fee.
Alternatives
Bitwarden is a password manager we have also reviewed. See our Bitwarden review. Pick it if you want a free plan, a lower price or public code.
- According to its pricing page (checked November 10, 2026), the free plan covers unlimited devices and passwords, and Premium is $1.65 a month billed yearly.
- Free accounts can use FIDO2 security keys. Emergency access needs Premium. It lets a trusted contact request your vault after a wait time you set.
- Its web, browser, desktop and command-line apps are public on GitHub. Its audit page lists at least one outside assessment in every year from 2020 to 2025, with years but no exact dates.
Bitwarden has had problems too. On April 22, 2026, a malicious version of its command-line tool was published on npm (a code library site) for about an hour and a half. Bitwarden’s statement says it found no evidence that vault data was at risk. In the ETH Zurich study, Help Net Security counted 12 attack scenarios against Bitwarden and 3 against 1Password. Bitwarden says most are fixed or being fixed. The Hacker News said Bitwarden released a version to address the clickjacking research. We found no independent review of its autofill to compare.
Pick 1Password if you prefer its Secret Key design and its apps and sharing, and the price suits you.
Not sure which setup fits you? Use the setup finder.
Buy only from the official site. Scammers sell tampered devices on marketplaces and run lookalike stores.
Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method.
Compare 1Password with
Sources
- Vendor: 1Password pricing (checked November 10, 2026)
- Vendor: 1Password terms of service (last updated November 2, 2026)
- Vendor: 1Password security
- Vendor: 1Password product page
- Vendor: 1Password Security Design White Paper, key security features
- Vendor: About your Secret Key
- Vendor: Security assessments
- Vendor: 1Password Trust Center
- Vendor community: Open source and security glossary entry
- Vendor: Response to the ETH Zurich research (February 16, 2026)
- Help Net Security: Password manager weaknesses in vault attacks (February 17, 2026)
- Vendor: Two-factor authentication
- Vendor: Security key as a second factor
- Vendor: Passkeys
- Vendor: System requirements
- Vendor: Recovery codes
- Vendor: Family account recovery
- Vendor: Emergency Kit
- Vendor community: Access after death and legacy contacts thread
- Vendor: Item categories (Crypto Wallet)
- CyberInsider: 1Password review (February 26, 2026, carries an affiliate disclosure)
- Vendor: Okta incident (September to October 2023)
- TechTarget: 1Password stops attack linked to Okta breach (October 24, 2023)
- Vendor advisory: CVE-2024-42219 (August 6, 2024)
- Vendor advisory: CVE-2024-42218 (August 6, 2024)
- Vendor advisory: DOM-based extension clickjacking (August 21, 2025)
- The Hacker News: DOM-based extension clickjacking (August 20, 2025)
- Vendor advisory: browser extension automatic sign-in (June 19, 2026)
- Vendor advisory: eMudhra certificate authority keys (October 28, 2026)
- Vendor: 1Password for Linux stable release notes
- Vendor: Security advisories list
- Bitwarden: Pricing
- Bitwarden: Is Bitwarden audited?
- Bitwarden: Two-step login
- Bitwarden: Emergency access
- GitHub: Bitwarden clients repository
- Bitwarden: Statement on the Checkmarx supply chain incident (April 23, 2026)
- Bitwarden: ETH Zurich audit post (February 16, 2026)