7.0/10
ChainMatch score · Crypto tax software
Research-based Method v1.1 · scored November 10, 2026
| Criterion | Weight | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accuracy and coverage | 30% | 7.5 | Koinly lists close to 1,000 exchanges, wallets and blockchains, including all the big names, matches transfers between your own wallets automatically and gives every plan, even the free one, tools to find and fix errors, but bridges are only partly handled, and liquid staking and some staking and lesser-known DeFi activity can still need fixing by hand, and we found no independent test of how accurate its numbers are. |
| Country and form support | 20% | 7.0 | The top mark needs official forms for the US, UK, Canada and Australia, plus more countries. Koinly makes official forms for two of those four: the US (Form 8949, Schedule D and Schedule 1) and Canada (Schedule 3, crypto fields only). For the UK and Australia, Koinly's help article describes reports that list all the figures needed to file (HMRC Capital Gains Summary; ATO Summary for myATO), and doesn't say they are filled-in official forms. Local reports for Sweden, Finland, France and others lift it above the one-or-two-country level. |
| Data security | 20% | 5.5 | Koinly says its connections are read-only, it never needs your private keys and it encrypts your data. Its public pages document no built-in two-step login: a user request open since October 2021 is still marked in progress, and you only get Google's protection if you sign in with Google. Nobody has checked inside a signed-in account. In December 2025 Koinly warned users that an analytics company it used may have exposed their email addresses. |
| Ease of use | 15% | 7.5 | Setup is four steps (connect your accounts, wait, review warnings, download reports) and a reviewer names Koinly the best fit for beginners, but you have to add every account you have ever used and fix flagged problems before the report is right, which takes some learning if your history is messy. |
| Value | 15% | 7.5 | You can import up to 10,000 transactions and see your gains for every year free before you pay, and prices are shown upfront with no subscription ($49 to $299 per tax year for up to 10,000 transactions, with paid top-ups above that), but each tax year's reports are paid for separately, your plans together must cover your whole history unless earlier years add up to fewer than 1,000 transactions (so a long history can force a bigger plan), big histories get expensive, and the pricing page's 'no questions asked' refund conflicts with Koinly's refund policy, which only covers Koinly bugs. |
Score limits that apply: a serious incident in the last 24 months that has been fixed (8.0 at most). How the limits work
Good
- The Free plan lets you connect unlimited wallets and exchange accounts, import up to 10,000 transactions and preview your gains and income summary for every year before you pay, according to Koinly's pricing page and help center (checked November 4, 2026).
- Paid plans are one-time payments for each tax year, not subscriptions: $49 for up to 100 transactions, $99 for 1,000, $199 for 3,000 and from $299 for 10,000. Above 10,000, you buy extra transactions in packs of 1,000. Koinly says it will not charge automatically.
- Koinly's help center says its US report contains Form 8949, Schedule D and Schedule 1, with exports for TurboTax and TaxAct. Koinly's tax page also lists local reports for Canada, the UK, Australia, Sweden, France, Finland, Denmark and Switzerland.
- According to Koinly, its connections are read-only, it needs no private keys, and it encrypts the API and blockchain keys it stores. These are company statements.
- Koinly's pricing page lists smart transfer matching, automatic balance checks, negative balance warnings, bulk editing and spam detection on every plan, including Free. Koinly's help center says the 'Bulk edit in Excel' tool and the Cost analysis tab need a paid plan.
- Coin Bureau (September 30, 2026) calls Koinly its 'best general-purpose choice', picks it for beginners in its user-type table and gives it the 'cleanest reconciliation workflow' label. It gives no Koinly-specific error rates.
Watch out for
- Koinly's public pages document no built-in two-step login. A request for it on Koinly's feedback board, posted October 27, 2021, was still marked 'In progress' with 808 votes on November 4, 2026. We couldn't sign in to an account to check its settings. If you sign in with Google, only Google's own protection applies, and linking Google turns off password login.
- In December 2025 Koinly emailed users about a possible email address leak after a security incident at its analytics provider, Mixpanel. Koinly says it was not a breach of its own systems and that no wallet, transaction or tax data was exposed. It gave no user count or date in the coverage we read.
- Accuracy depends on your data. Koinly's own guides say missing purchase history can give an asset a cost of zero, and Coin Bureau's DeFi table marks Koinly's bridge support 'Transfer matching/partial' and liquid staking tokens 'Partial/manual'. We found no independent accuracy test.
- For the UK and Australia, Koinly's tax reports article says its reports list 'all the figures needed' to file with HMRC and the ATO. It doesn't say they are filled-in copies of an official form. Its Canada Schedule 3 has only the crypto fields filled in.
- Each tax year is paid separately, prices rise with transaction count, and your plans together must cover your whole history unless your earlier years add up to fewer than 1,000 transactions. Coin Bureau lists the lack of an unlimited plan and the cost of high transaction counts as drawbacks.
- Koinly's pricing page promises a refund 'no questions asked' within 7 days. Its refund policy says the reason must be a Koinly bug or issue the team can't resolve.
- Koinly's 'Is Koinly Secure?' article names no auditor for its security audits, and we couldn't open the 'Certifications and compliance' page it links to. Coin Bureau says Koinly publishes SOC 2 and ISO 27001 certification, but we couldn't open a certificate or report to check.
Who it’s for
Koinly is crypto tax software. It imports your trades, transfers and income from exchanges and wallets, then works out the gains and losses you report to your tax office. It suits anyone who has sold, swapped, spent or earned crypto and has to file.
ChainMatch hasn’t tied it to one profile, because anyone with taxable activity may need a tool like this. The Newcomer with one or two accounts can connect them for free and see a summary before paying. The Active User, with many accounts and thousands of transactions, should expect a higher price and more cleanup.
It is a weaker fit if your history is full of newer DeFi apps (programs that run on a blockchain instead of at a company). It is also weaker if you want documented login protection beyond a password and Google’s own tools.
This is a research-based review. It rests on Koinly’s documentation, news coverage and an independent reviewer’s write-up. See how we score crypto tax software. This isn’t tax advice. Rules differ by country, so check with a tax professional or your tax authority.
What you get and what it costs
Koinly’s pricing page (checked November 4, 2026) lists these plans. Every plan allows unlimited wallets and exchange accounts. Prices are per tax year.
- Free, $0. You can connect wallets, import transactions and preview your gains and income summary for every year. It leaves out Form 8949 and Schedule D (the main US forms for reporting crypto sales), international tax reports, TurboTax and TaxAct export, and chat support. Koinly’s help center (June 23, 2026) says Free allows up to 10,000 transactions. If you go over, all calculations stop until you pay for a plan that covers the full count.
- Newbie, $49. Up to 100 transactions.
- Hodler, $99. Up to 1,000.
- Trader, $199. Up to 3,000.
- Pro, from $299. Up to 10,000. Above that, you add packs of 1,000 transactions in the app.
The pricing page says each plan is a one-time payment for one tax year, not a subscription, and that Koinly won’t charge you automatically. Its FAQ says you buy extra transactions above 10,000 in the app, 1,000 at a time. Koinly’s help center says extra transactions are a Pro-only add-on.
Koinly also has an account-wide limit. Its pricing article (June 23, 2026) says “all plans combined need to cover all transactions”, though earlier years don’t need covering if they add up to fewer than 1,000 transactions. So your plan must cover the year you file, and your plans together must cover your whole history. In Koinly’s own example, someone with 137 transactions in 2023 but nearly 3,000 in total needs the 3,000-transaction plan. One larger plan for a recent year can cover older years’ transactions, but it doesn’t let you make reports for those years.
The pricing page promises a full refund within 7 days if you haven’t generated a tax report, “no questions asked”. Koinly’s refund policy (February 26, 2026) is stricter. It says you get a refund only if all three of these are true:
- You ask within 7 days.
- The reason is a Koinly bug or issue the team can’t resolve in a reasonable time.
- You haven’t generated a tax report.
Plan on the stricter version.
What it covers
- Accounts. Koinly says it syncs with “1000+ direct integrations” and accepts unlimited CSV imports (spreadsheet files you download from an exchange). Those are its own figures, and they differ: its home page says 900+ in one place and 800+ in another. Its integrations page names close to 1,000 exchanges, wallets and blockchains, including Coinbase, Kraken, Gemini, MetaMask, Phantom, Ledger, Trezor, Exodus, Tangem Wallet, Rabby Wallet, Sparrow Wallet and Keystone Wallet.
- Mistake-finding tools. Koinly’s home page says it tracks transfers between your own wallets automatically and keeps their original cost basis (what you first paid for the coins). The pricing page lists smart transfer matching, automatic balance checks, warnings for negative balances, bulk editing and spam detection on all plans. Koinly’s help center says the “Bulk edit in Excel” tool and the Cost analysis tab need a paid plan.
- An independent view. Coin Bureau calls Koinly its “best general-purpose choice” and its pick for beginners. It gives Koinly the “cleanest reconciliation workflow” label, citing transfer matching, balance checks and visible warnings. Coin Bureau says some links in its guides may be affiliate links. It gives no Koinly-specific error rates or accuracy test results.
- Countries and forms. Koinly’s tax page lists local reports for the US (IRS Form 8949 and Schedule D), Australia, the UK, Canada, Sweden, France, Finland, Denmark and Switzerland. According to its tax reports article, the US report also has Schedule 1 and exports for TurboTax Online, TurboTax Desktop and TaxAct. The Canada report fills in only the crypto fields of Schedule 3 and leaves the rest empty. For the UK and Australia, Koinly says its reports list all the figures you need to file.
- Other countries. Koinly’s tax page says it covers over 20 countries. Its help center says it supports over 100 and names 31. It says its Complete Tax Report works for countries that use a standard way to work out cost. Examples are FIFO (first in, first out: the coins you bought first count as sold first), LIFO (last in, first out), HIFO (highest cost, first out) and average cost. Check your country on Koinly’s list before you pay.
How it keeps you safe
These are Koinly’s own statements unless noted. We couldn’t confirm them independently.
- Read-only access, no private keys. Koinly’s security page (revised July 19, 2023) says it doesn’t need private keys or access to the funds on your exchanges. It says it always recommends turning off withdrawal and trading permissions on API keys. An API key is a code you create on an exchange that lets another app view your account. Its “Is Koinly Secure?” article (June 17, 2026) says all OAuth connections (sign-in links between two services) and APIs are read-only. It says that means Koinly can only import your transaction history.
- Encryption. The security page says API and blockchain keys are encrypted with AES-256-GCM (a widely used encryption standard) before they’re stored. The 2026 article says data is encrypted in transit and at rest.
- Card payments go through Stripe. The 2026 article says Koinly doesn’t store your card details because payments go through Stripe. Its privacy policy says billing information may be kept as long as the law requires. The same article says the only thing you need to use Koinly is a valid email address. Name, address and tax ID are optional.
- Sign-in choices. The security page says you can sign in with Google or Coinbase, in which case Koinly stores no password. Email sign-ups have passwords stored using bcrypt (a method that scrambles passwords so they can’t be read back).
- It doesn’t report you. A Koinly help article (June 24, 2026) says Koinly doesn’t send reports to the IRS, HMRC, ATO or any other tax office. Its privacy policy (revised January 1, 2026) says it will never sell or trade your data. It also lists analytics companies among the service providers that may receive your data. And it says it may disclose information to respond to subpoenas, court orders or other legal requests.
- You can delete your data yourself. A help article (May 5, 2026) says you can delete your account from Settings. That permanently erases all account data from Koinly’s servers and can’t be undone.
- Scam warnings. Koinly’s scam article (April 15, 2026) says it will never ask for your recovery phrase (the 12 or 24 words that unlock a wallet), payment outside the Plans page, money to activate or unfreeze an account, forms on third-party websites, or coupon codes and gift cards.
Where it falls short
No built-in two-step login is documented. Two-step login asks for a second proof, such as a code from an app, when you sign in. Koinly’s public pages describe none of its own. We couldn’t sign in to an account, so we can’t rule out a setting those pages don’t mention. A request for it on Koinly’s feedback board was posted on October 27, 2021 and was still marked “In progress” with 808 votes on November 4, 2026.
A Koinly staff reply dated December 15, 2025 says the feature is “still on our internal roadmap and is marked as in progress”. The same reply says signing in with Google, with 2-step verification on your Google account, is an interim option. It adds that this is “not the same as having native 2FA/MFA directly on Koinly accounts”.
According to Koinly’s login help article (June 8, 2026), once you link a Google account, password login is turned off and you can only use “Continue with Google”. We found no Koinly help article on authenticator-app, passkey or security-key login. Your account holds your transaction history, so the login matters.
December 2025: Koinly warned of a possible email leak at an analytics vendor. Crypto Briefing reported on December 23, 2025 that Koinly emailed users about a possible email address leak. It followed a security incident at Mixpanel, a third-party analytics provider (a company that measures how people use a website). The report says the exposure appears limited to email addresses. Koinly said wallet data, transactions, tax reports and portfolio data were not shared with Mixpanel. It gave no user count or date. Value The Markets reported the same day that Koinly was investigating with Mixpanel and said it was working to keep its systems secure.
On December 29, 2025, a Koinly staff reply on its feedback board said Koinly “did not experience a data breach” and that no wallet addresses, transaction data or tax data were exposed. It said Koinly has stopped using the provider, is reviewing all its third-party integrations and emailed users a detailed explanation.
In its own post of November 27, 2025, Mixpanel said it detected a text-message phishing attack (a fake message that tricks someone into handing over a login) on November 8, 2025. It said a limited number of customers were affected. The post doesn’t name Koinly or say what data was taken. We found no independent report on what was exposed, and we couldn’t open Koinly’s email to users.
Our method limits the grade of any product with a serious incident in the last 24 months, even a fixed one, and we applied that limit here. It doesn’t lower Koinly’s grade by itself. But the incident and the lack of a documented two-step login are why its data security mark is only middling.
Your numbers are only as good as your data. Koinly’s getting-started guide (June 23, 2026) says accuracy depends on what you import. Unresolved issues show in a “Review needed” section of the Tax Reports page. Some assets may get a cost of zero if their purchase history is missing. Koinly’s home page warns that without the right cost basis “you could significantly overpay.”
Koinly’s help center (July 11, 2025) says some exchanges and blockchains don’t provide complete histories. That can cause balance errors and missing cost-basis errors. Its accuracy guide (June 27, 2025) tells you to import every exchange and self-custody wallet you’ve used, including closed ones and every layer 2 network (a faster network built on top of another one). It also tells you to check DeFi activity, NFT trades (trades of unique digital items such as art) and unmatched transfers by hand.
Coin Bureau compared three tools: Koinly, CoinTracking and CoinLedger. It says that with all three, unusual contracts, newer protocols and complicated liquidity positions (crypto you’ve added to a trading pool) can still need manual classification. It also says that, for any of them, fast setup doesn’t mean a messy history will be quick to clean up.
Coin Bureau’s guide marks Koinly’s handling of bridges (services that move crypto between networks) as “Transfer matching/partial” and liquid staking tokens (tokens you receive for staking) as “Partial/manual”. We found no independent accuracy test. Koinly’s DeFi import guide is dated October 1, 2024, more than two years ago, so some steps may have changed.
Cost grows with activity. Coin Bureau lists the lack of an unlimited plan, the cost of high transaction counts and the need to pay for downloadable reports as drawbacks. Koinly’s account-wide limit (see above) can also push a long history onto a bigger plan.
Security claims we couldn’t check. The security page, dated July 19, 2023, says Koinly is hosted on Heroku. The June 2026 article says the vast majority of its services and data are on Amazon Web Services in the USA and that it is consolidating there. The article also says Koinly regularly engages third-party auditors to audit its code and infrastructure. It names no auditor. It links to a Koinly “Certifications and compliance” page, which we couldn’t open. Coin Bureau says Koinly “also publishes SOC 2 and ISO 27001 certification” (common security audit standards). We couldn’t open a certificate or audit report, so we can’t say what type, who audited or when.
What customers say. Trustpilot showed a 4.5 out of 5 TrustScore from 2,387 reviews on November 10, 2026, with 85% five-star and 4% one-star. These are self-reported and we haven’t verified them. Koinly has claimed its Trustpilot profile and pays for a Trustpilot subscription. Trustpilot says it doesn’t fact-check reviews. A keyword search for “koinly” in the US National Vulnerability Database returned no entries on November 4, 2026. That shows no listed software flaws, not that none exist.
Setting it up safely
- Start at koinly.io. Type the address yourself. Don’t follow a link in an email, ad or message. Koinly’s scam article lists scams aimed at its users, such as a fake fee to “unfreeze” lost funds and an email asking for a “reconciliation check”.
- Never share your recovery phrase. It’s also called a seed phrase. Koinly says it will never ask for it, and it doesn’t need one. Add wallets by public address (the address anyone can see, not a secret) or by file. See our 60-second scam check.
- Make exchange keys read-only. When you create an API key on an exchange, allow viewing only. Leave withdrawals and trading switched off, as Koinly’s security page recommends. Delete the key on the exchange when you’re done.
- Protect your Koinly login yourself. Koinly’s public pages document no built-in two-step login, so look in your account settings first. If you find none, you have two options. Sign in with Google and turn on 2-step verification in your Google account, which Koinly staff name as an interim option. Linking Google turns off password login, so your Google account becomes the key to Koinly. Or sign up with email, a long password you use nowhere else, and a well-protected email account.
- Expect phishing emails. Email addresses are all a phishing message needs. Doubt any email that claims to be from Koinly, especially one about fees, a frozen account or a refund. Koinly says it will never take payment outside the Plans page.
- Preview before you pay. Connect every account, then work through the “Review needed” list and the “Missing purchase history” warnings. Pay only when the summary looks right.
- Don’t generate a report until you’re sure. Both Koinly’s pricing page and its refund policy say a refund is off once you’ve generated a tax report.
- Check the hard parts by hand. For DeFi, NFTs and bridges, follow Koinly’s guides, or ask a tax professional.
- When you’re done, download your reports first. Deleting your account can’t be undone.
If a scammer has contacted you or taken money, report it to the FBI at ic3.gov and the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov. Elsewhere, use your national fraud service. Ignore anyone who offers to recover lost funds for a fee.
Alternatives
CoinTracker is another crypto tax tool ChainMatch has researched and scored. See our CoinTracker review. It is a different trade-off.
- According to its pricing page (checked November 4, 2026), paid plans on the “Regular” option start at $59 a year for up to 100 transactions, then $199 for 1,000 and $499 for 10,000. For 100 or 1,000 transactions in one year, Koinly’s sticker prices are lower ($49 and $99). But the two count differently. CoinTracker counts only the year you file, up to a 200,000 lifetime limit on those paid plans. Koinly’s plans together must cover your whole history, unless your earlier years add up to fewer than 1,000 transactions. So a long history can push you onto a bigger Koinly plan. CoinTracker says one plan covers tax forms for every past year, while Koinly sells each year separately.
- CoinTracker’s help article says it supports two-step login with authenticator apps (apps that make one-time codes). It doesn’t mention security keys or passkeys. A CoinTracker reply on Trustpilot (October 23, 2026) says Google sign-in relies on the Google account’s own protection, as with Koinly.
- Protos reported on November 27, 2025 that attackers who breached Mixpanel exported CoinTracker user data. It listed email addresses, approximate locations, device details and summaries of users’ transactions.
- Two CoinTracker help articles (read November 10, 2026) tell you to use your recovery phrase outside your wallet. Its Trust Wallet article says to paste it into a separate key tool, and its Coinbase Wallet article says to copy it into another wallet. Neither asks you to give it to CoinTracker. Don’t follow those steps. Never type your recovery phrase into a tool or website.
Pick CoinTracker if you want an authenticator-app login on an email account or one plan for several past years. Pick Koinly if you have a short history and want the lowest price for one tax year.
Not sure which setup fits you? Use the setup finder.
Buy only from the official site. Scammers sell tampered devices on marketplaces and run lookalike stores.
Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method.
Work out what Koinly costs for your transaction count, next to the other tax tools we've scored.
Compare Koinly with
Sources
- Koinly: Pricing (checked November 4, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Tax plans (June 23, 2026)
- Koinly Help: How pricing works (June 23, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Koinly's refund policy (February 26, 2026)
- Koinly: Integrations (checked November 4, 2026)
- Koinly: Home page (checked November 4, 2026)
- Koinly: Tax reports by country (checked November 4, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Koinly tax reports (June 23, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Which countries does Koinly calculate taxes for (August 11, 2026)
- Koinly: Security (revised July 19, 2023)
- Koinly Help: Is Koinly secure (June 17, 2026)
- Koinly: Privacy policy (revised January 1, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Does Koinly report to the government (June 24, 2026)
- Koinly Help: How do I delete my account (May 5, 2026)
- Koinly Help: Beware of scam attempts (April 15, 2026)
- Koinly Help: How do I change my email or login method (June 8, 2026)
- Koinly feedback board: 2FA / MFA options (checked November 4, 2026)
- Koinly feedback board: staff reply on the third-party incident (December 29, 2025)
- Crypto Briefing: Koinly email leak after Mixpanel incident (December 23, 2025)
- Value The Markets: Koinly faces potential email address leak (December 23, 2025)
- Mixpanel: SMS security incident (November 27, 2025)
- Koinly Help: Getting started with Koinly (June 23, 2026)
- Koinly Help: API sync limitations (July 11, 2025)
- Koinly Help: How to ensure your tax report is accurate (June 27, 2025)
- Koinly Help: How to import data from DeFi protocols (October 1, 2024)
- Coin Bureau: Best crypto tax software (updated September 1, 2026)
- Coin Bureau: CoinTracking vs Koinly vs CoinLedger (updated September 30, 2026)
- US National Vulnerability Database: keyword search for koinly (November 4, 2026)
- Trustpilot: Koinly reviews (checked November 10, 2026)
- CoinTracker: Pricing (checked November 4, 2026)
- CoinTracker Help: Set up two-factor authentication
- Trustpilot: CoinTracker reviews (staff reply of October 23, 2026)
- CoinTracker Help: Add your Trust Wallet to CoinTracker (read November 10, 2026)
- CoinTracker Help: Add BCH, ETC, XLM, or XRP wallets from Coinbase Wallet (read November 10, 2026)
- Protos: CoinTracker user data leaked after Mixpanel hack (November 27, 2025)