Compare products · Crypto tax software

Koinly vs CoinLedger

Koinly scores 7.0 out of 10 and CoinLedger scores 6.5 by our method.

What the scores say

  • Koinly scores higher on accuracy and coverage, data security, and value.
  • They score the same on country and form support, and ease of use.

A higher score doesn't make a product right for you. The setup finder matches crypto tax software to how you'll use crypto.

MeasureKoinlyKoinlyRead reviewVisit KoinlyCoinLedgerCoinLedgerRead reviewVisit CoinLedger
Scores
ChainMatch score0 to 10, from the criteria below. How we score7.06.5
Accuracy and coverage30% of the score.7.5
Why

Koinly lists close to 1,000 exchanges, wallets and blockchains, including all the big names, matches transfers between your own wallets automatically and gives every plan, even the free one, tools to find and fix errors, but bridges are only partly handled, and liquid staking and some staking and lesser-known DeFi activity can still need fixing by hand, and we found no independent test of how accurate its numbers are.

source
7.0
Why

CoinLedger says it connects to 1,000+ exchanges, wallets and blockchains (including Coinbase, Kraken, MetaMask and Phantom) and spots most transfers between your own wallets by itself, but bridges and liquid staking can need fixing by hand, a CPA firm that sells tax services calls its DeFi (blockchain finance app) handling and editing tools limited, and we found no independent test of how accurate its numbers are.

source
Country and form support20% of the score.7.0
Why

The top mark needs official forms for the US, UK, Canada and Australia, plus more countries. Koinly makes official forms for two of those four: the US (Form 8949, Schedule D and Schedule 1) and Canada (Schedule 3, crypto fields only). For the UK and Australia, Koinly's help article describes reports that list all the figures needed to file (HMRC Capital Gains Summary; ATO Summary for myATO), and doesn't say they are filled-in official forms. Local reports for Sweden, Finland, France and others lift it above the one-or-two-country level.

source
7.0
Why

It makes official US forms (Form 8949 and Schedule 1), Canada's Schedule 3 and an ATO form for Australia, but UK users get a capital gains summary rather than a filled-in HMRC form, New Zealand's IR3 and the US Schedule D are named only on a sales page and not in its help guides, and other countries get general reports in their own currency.

source
Data security20% of the score.5.5
Why

Koinly says its connections are read-only, it never needs your private keys and it encrypts your data. Its public pages document no built-in two-step login: a user request open since October 2021 is still marked in progress, and you only get Google's protection if you sign in with Google. Nobody has checked inside a signed-in account. In December 2025 Koinly warned users that an analytics company it used may have exposed their email addresses.

source
4.0
Why

Exchange connections are read-only and it never asks for withdrawal access. But it only says it encrypts data while it travels, not stored data or saved exchange keys, and its public pages document no two-step login of its own (the only option described is signing in through Google or Coinbase). Its documented password hashing (the scrambling of stored passwords: 10,000 PBKDF2 iterations, October 2024) is far below the 600,000 that the security nonprofit OWASP recommends. An analytics company it used leaked users' names, emails and rough locations in November 2025. One help article points Trust Wallet users to a recovery phrase tool with only a vague caution.

source
Ease of use15% of the score.7.5
Why

Setup is four steps (connect your accounts, wait, review warnings, download reports) and a reviewer names Koinly the best fit for beginners, but you have to add every account you have ever used and fix flagged problems before the report is right, which takes some learning if your history is messy.

source
7.5
Why

Getting started takes four steps (add your accounts, clear flagged warnings, buy the year's report, download it) and reviewers call it easy and well guided, with guides for TurboTax, TaxAct, H&R Block and TaxSlayer, but you must add every account you have ever used and fix missing-cost warnings first, and one reviewer recommends Koinly over it for beginners.

source
Value15% of the score.7.5
Why

You can import up to 10,000 transactions and see your gains for every year free before you pay, and prices are shown upfront with no subscription ($49 to $299 per tax year for up to 10,000 transactions, with paid top-ups above that), but each tax year's reports are paid for separately, your plans together must cover your whole history unless earlier years add up to fewer than 1,000 transactions (so a long history can force a bigger plan), big histories get expensive, and the pricing page's 'no questions asked' refund conflicts with Koinly's refund policy, which only covers Koinly bugs.

source
7.0
Why

You can see each year's gains, losses and income free before you pay, and reports cost $49, $99 or $199 per tax year for up to 100, 1,000 or 3,000 transactions with no subscription, but the pricing page doesn't show what bigger histories cost (a help article says $499 at 10,000 or more), and the home page's 14-day money-back promise is narrower in the refund policy, which only covers bugs and only if you haven't downloaded a report.

source
Serious security problemsAn unfixed problem limits the score to 4.0. A flaw in the product itself that has cost customers money, with users still at risk, limits it to 0.0. A serious incident in the last 24 months that has been fixed limits it to 8.0. Older ones are in the review. How we scoreFixed, last 24 monthsFixed, last 24 months
Details
SetupHow much experience it takes to set up.Beginner-friendlyBeginner-friendly
Coins and networksWhat it works with.Many blockchainsMany blockchains
How we checked itHands-on means a person on our team used it.ResearchResearch
Last scoredWhen we last scored it.Nov 2026Nov 2026
Features
Free planYesYes

Highlighted cells are the better of the two. Scores: 7–10 4–6.9 0–3.9

We list a feature only when a source confirms it. "Not confirmed" means we haven't found one, not that the feature is missing. Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method. How we score crypto tax software.

More comparisons

Koinly vs

CoinLedger vs