Compare products · Hardware wallets
Keystone 3 Pro vs Coldcard Mk5
Keystone 3 Pro scores 4.0 out of 10 and Coldcard Mk5 scores 0.0 by our method.
What the scores say
- Keystone 3 Pro scores higher on security design, track record, ease of use and value.
- Coldcard Mk5 scores higher on recovery and backup.
- They score the same on scam resistance.
- Keystone 3 Pro has an unfixed security problem, which holds its score at 4.0. Its criteria alone would give 6.7.
- Coldcard Mk5 has a flaw in the product itself that has cost customers money and still puts people who used it at risk, which holds its score at 0.0. Its criteria alone would give 5.2.
A higher score doesn't make a product right for you. The setup finder matches hardware wallets to how you'll use crypto.
| Measure | Keystone 3 ProKeystoneRead reviewVisit Keystone | Coldcard Mk5CoinkiteRead reviewVisit Coinkite |
|---|---|---|
| Scores | ||
| ChainMatch score0 to 10, from the criteria below. How we score | 4.0 | 0.0 |
| Security design25% of the score. | 8.0WhyYour keys sit behind three secure chips, the main firmware is open source (MIT) and was independently rebuilt for version 3.2.0, and you can add a passphrase, but the chip library that reads QR codes is closed, and the only audit report we could find (Keylabs, November 2023) is about three years old, predates today's firmware and left screen and case tamper gaps unfixed; the 'View audits' link on Keystone's site is dead. | 6.0WhyYour keys are protected by two secure chips from different makers working with the main chip, you can add a passphrase, and the firmware code is public and an outside reviewer rebuilt version 5.6.0 byte for byte, but the code's licence bars selling it (so it is not open source in the usual sense), no full independent audit of current firmware has been published (Coinkite's status page says so, although its launch post called the firmware 'audited'), a build mistake dating from 2021 meant recovery phrases made on firmware before 5.6.0 (July 31, 2026; Edge: 6.6.0X) got far weaker randomness than intended, and Ledger's 2023 paper says a lab laser attack reads the protected memory pages of one of the two secure chips with a 99% success rate and can be repeated within a day, though Coinkite says the recovery phrase was not extracted. |
| Scam resistance20% of the score. | 7.0WhyThe large 4-inch touchscreen shows transaction details, and the firmware warns about token 'Permit' signatures and about data it cannot decode, but reading many app requests needs Keystone's contract files on a microSD card (not in the box) kept inserted while signing, otherwise you see raw encoded data, and the blind-signing notice can be turned off with 'Do not remind again'. | 7.0WhyThe Mk5 reads each Bitcoin transaction and shows you what it will sign so you can check the destination and amount before approving, and it blocks or warns about unusual signing types and far-future time locks, but the 1.54-inch screen is small, and until firmware 5.6.1 in August 2026 a hacked computer could swap in a different transaction after you had reviewed the one on screen (with a related Virtual Disk fix in 5.6.2 in September). |
| Track record20% of the score. | 3.5WhyIn October 2026 an attacker broke into Keystone's website, exposing the names, contact details and addresses in 25,964 buyer records (data Keystone's 180-day deletion policy should have removed), and took the key used to prove its devices are genuine; Keystone disclosed the full scope within six days and runs a public bug bounty, but on November 10, 2026 its statement still described destroying old-key stock as a plan and carried neither the result of the data erasure it expected to finish on November 3 nor the detailed report it promised, on November 6 it said a cyberattack had hit some of its Nexus app services (it said it found no evidence that assets or personal information were affected), and its firmware notes list unexplained 'enhanced security' changes with no published security advisories. | 2.0WhyFrom July 30, 2026, thieves drained bitcoin worth about $70 million to $130 million, according to press reports of Galaxy Research's counts, from wallets whose recovery phrases COLDCARDs had made with weak randomness, a bug that sat unnoticed from 2021 and also covers recovery phrases the Mk5 made before firmware 5.6.0 (Edge: 6.6.0X); Coinkite shipped fixed firmware within about a day and has published an unusually detailed public record, but its first advisory said the Mk5 was not affected, Privacy Guides reported its advisory came about 30 hours after the first thefts, its disclosure history lists a paid 2022 review that examined random-number generation, Coinkite says earlier reviews did not check which random function phrase-making used, a separate September 2025 flaw let private keys be recovered, its full technical postmortem is still unpublished, no victim compensation has been reported, and its bug bounty is discretionary with no published rewards. |
| Ease of use15% of the score. | 7.0WhyThe large touchscreen walks you through creating and checking your 24-word backup on the device with no app needed, but to see balances or send you must pair a separate wallet app by scanning QR codes, Keystone's own guides disagree about whether USB works, and a review notes a learning curve for advanced features. | 4.0WhySetup needs the manual: you must install and verify a firmware update yourself before making a wallet, every new wallet asks for 50 dice rolls, 128 coin flips or 65 key presses, there is no required COLDCARD app so you choose and set up separate wallet software yourself, and its many advanced features sit behind a small 1.54-inch screen and keypad. |
| Recovery and backup10% of the score. | 9.0WhyYour 24-word recovery phrase is the standard kind other wallets can read, and you can instead create a wallet backed up as Shamir (SLIP-39) shares, or use Bitcoin multisig, though Keystone warns that some coins may not appear in other brands' wallets because they use different account paths. | 9.5WhyYour 24-word recovery phrase is the standard BIP-39 kind other wallets can read, and the Mk5 also supports multi-signature wallets, Codex32 split backups of two to nine shares (added in September 2026) and encrypted MicroSD backups that any 7z tool can open, though Codex32 shares are saved as plain text and need careful storage. |
| Value10% of the score. | 6.0WhyAt $149 it costs more than the Trezor Safe 5 ($129, smaller 1.54-inch touchscreen) and less than the Ledger Flex ($249), which is fair for a 4-inch touchscreen, camera and fingerprint reader, but the standard warranty is one year (two years costs $50 more) and the microSD card used for app decoding is extra; there is no subscription. | 3.0WhyAt $219 (shown beside a crossed-out $269) it costs well above secure-chip wallets such as the Trezor Safe 5 ($129) and Keystone 3 Pro ($149 with one year of cover), the USB cable is extra, and Coinkite's terms sell it 'as-is' as a final sale with no stated warranty period and no refunds, though there is no subscription. |
| Serious security problemsAn unfixed problem limits the score to 4.0. A flaw in the product itself that has cost customers money, with users still at risk, limits it to 0.0. A serious incident in the last 24 months that has been fixed limits it to 8.0. Older ones are in the review. How we score | Unfixed problem | Flaw cost customers money, users still at risk |
| Details | ||
| PriceAt the maker's own store, in US dollars. | $149source · Nov 2026 | $219source · Nov 2026 |
| SetupHow much experience it takes to set up. | Some experience needed | For experienced users |
| Coins and networksWhat it works with. | Many blockchains | Bitcoin only |
| How we checked itHands-on means a person on our team used it. | Research | Research |
| Last scoredWhen we last scored it. | Nov 2026 | Nov 2026 |
| Features | ||
| Open source | Yes | Not confirmed |
| Keys on a tamper-resistant chip | Yes | Yes |
| Works without connecting to a computer | Yes | Yes |
| Touchscreen | Yes | Not confirmed |
| Works with phones by tap (NFC) | Not confirmed | Yes |
| Phone app | Yes | Not confirmed |
Highlighted cells are the better of the two. Scores: 7–10 4–6.9 0–3.9
We list a feature only when a source confirms it. "Not confirmed" means we haven't found one, not that the feature is missing. Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method. How we score hardware wallets.