How we score · version 1.1
How we score hardware wallets
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Security design | 25% |
| Scam resistance | 20% |
| Track record | 20% |
| Ease of use | 15% |
| Recovery and backup | 10% |
| Value | 10% |
A hardware wallet is a small device that keeps the keys to your crypto offline, so malware on your phone or computer can’t reach them. We score them on six criteria. For each one, a reviewer picks a score from 0 to 10 using the descriptions below and cites the sources behind it.
Security design
What we look at: how the device stores your keys, whether its software can be inspected, and how it resists physical attacks.
- 10: Keys kept on a tamper-resistant chip (a “secure element”) or an equivalent design. Firmware is open source or has a recent, published independent audit. Supports an optional extra passphrase.
- 5: Has either tamper-resistant storage or open, audited firmware, but not both. Or audits are more than three years old.
- 0: Keys kept in ordinary memory, closed firmware and no independent audit.
Scam resistance
What we look at: whether you can see and confirm what you’re approving on the device itself, before it’s too late.
- 10: Shows readable transaction details (recipient, amount, what an app is asking for) on a screen big enough to check them. Warns you before “blind signing” anything it can’t read.
- 5: Shows addresses and amounts, but many app actions have to be approved blind.
- 0: No screen, or no way to check what you’re approving.
Track record
What we look at: past security problems, data leaks and how the company handled them. Customer data leaks count because they lead to targeted phishing.
- 10: No serious incidents in five years. Problems are disclosed quickly and openly. Runs a public bug bounty.
- 5: A serious incident in the past, handled openly and fixed.
- 0: Repeated or hidden incidents, or slow fixes.
The security caps apply on top of this score.
Ease of use
What we look at: setup, the companion app, the screen and buttons, and help documentation.
- 10: A beginner can set it up, back it up and send a test transaction without outside help.
- 5: Setup works but needs the manual. Small screen or fiddly buttons.
- 0: Setup is confusing enough to cause mistakes, like skipping the backup.
Recovery and backup
What we look at: whether you can recover your crypto without the company, and with other wallets.
- 10: Standard recovery phrase that works with other wallets, plus advanced options such as split backups or multi-signature setups.
- 5: Standard recovery phrase only.
- 0: Recovery depends on the company or uses a format only its products can read.
Value
What we look at: price compared with similar devices, warranty and any ongoing costs.
- 10: Among the lowest prices for its features, with at least a two-year warranty.
- 5: About average for its features.
- 0: Expensive for what it offers, or needs a paid subscription for basic use.