Compare products · Recovery phrase backups
Cryptosteel Seed24 vs Billfodl
Cryptosteel Seed24 scores 6.2 out of 10 and Billfodl scores 5.0 by our method.
What the scores say
- Cryptosteel Seed24 scores higher on durability, security, compatibility and value.
- Billfodl scores higher on ease of use.
A higher score doesn't make a product right for you. The setup finder matches recovery phrase backups to how you'll use crypto.
| Measure | Cryptosteel Seed24Cryptosteel (Sword Ltd)Read reviewVisit Cryptosteel (Sword Ltd) | BillfodlBillfodlRead reviewVisit Billfodl |
|---|---|---|
| Scores | ||
| ChainMatch score0 to 10, from the criteria below. How we score | 6.2 | 5.0 |
| Durability35% of the score. | 5.0WhyIt is made of stainless steel and Cryptosteel says it survives fire up to 1400°C, water and corrosion, but we found no independent test of the Seed24 itself, so it scores at the level for metal backups with only the maker's claims; the older Cryptosteel Capsule passed Jameson Lopp's 2019 heat and acid tests and its words survived a 20-ton press (though the bent capsule could no longer be opened), but those results don't count here because the rod the tiles sit on is the part Cryptosteel redesigned for Seed24. | 4.0WhyIt is stainless steel, but in Jameson Lopp's 2018 tests a torch warped the tray so letter tiles fell out (he later agreed that torch heated unevenly) and after crushing nearly all the tiles fell out, earning heat C and crush D. His 2018 unit was unaffected by acid, but in 2019 the Blockstream Metal, which he calls a rebranded Billfodl, kept every tile under a larger propane torch and then lost every tile when acid dissolved its rivets. The big fire test that went well used a unit the maker gave away free and still needed scrubbing before every tile could be read. |
| Security20% of the score. | 8.0WhyIt has no electronics, app or account, and the kit comes with numbered plastic security seals that Cryptosteel says can't survive anyone opening the capsule, but fitting them is optional, we found no independent test of them, and if you keep the tile rod apart from its case, as Cryptosteel suggests you can, the seal doesn't protect it. | 5.5WhyIt is a steel case with no electronics, app or account, but it has no built-in tamper evidence, so you can only tell whether someone opened it if you add tamper stickers that break when it is opened or fit a padlock through the case. |
| Ease of use20% of the score. | 6.0WhyCryptosteel's step-by-step guide has you slide up to 96 letter tiles onto a rod by hand with no tools, then check your work by restoring your wallet from the backup, and you can fix mistakes by rearranging tiles, but it takes many manual steps, no source has timed it, and an independent reviewer found the older Capsule's tiles fairly annoying to read back. | 6.5WhyYou only store the first four letters of each word and reviewers call it easy once you work out how to open it, but no source times a full setup, opening takes several steps (Lopp's older unit needed a screwdriver and came with no instructions) and loose tiles can be misplaced, so it is slow and needs care. |
| Compatibility10% of the score. | 8.0WhyIt holds 12-word phrases in full and 24-word phrases cut to their first four letters, and Cryptosteel says it works with standard (BIP39 and SLIP39) wallets such as Ledger, Trezor, BitBox and Coldcard. The $50 kit's card lists letter tiles only, though Cryptosteel's FAQ says the Seed24 kit has every printable character, so a passphrase with numbers or symbols may need extra tiles. Cryptosteel's pages also disagree on whether it holds 123 or 128 characters, so check a passphrase fits beside a 24-word phrase. | 7.0WhyIt holds 12-, 18- and 24-word phrases and hex keys for standard wallets such as Ledger, Trezor and KeepKey, but its 96 letter slots are full with a 24-word phrase, so there is no room for an optional passphrase on the same unit. |
| Value15% of the score. | 5.5WhyAt $50 (a sale price; the regular price is $80) it costs less than most well-known metal backups in an August 2026 roundup, which ran from $45 to $139 apart from a $286 bundle, but its toughness rests only on the maker's word, while several backups that passed Jameson Lopp's independent tests cost the same or less, such as Seedplate at $50 and DIYSeed at $20. | 3.5WhyAt about $99 to $105 it costs more than Blockplate 24, Coinplate Alpha and Steelwallet ($65 to $83), which Lopp grades A for durability against its C, though a 360-day return policy that refunds 125% of the price on one unit lowers the risk of trying it. |
| Serious security problemsAn unfixed problem limits the score to 4.0. A flaw in the product itself that has cost customers money, with users still at risk, limits it to 0.0. A serious incident in the last 24 months that has been fixed limits it to 8.0. Older ones are in the review. How we score | None in the last 24 months | None in the last 24 months |
| Details | ||
| PriceAt the maker's own store, in US dollars. | $50source · Nov 2026 | $99source · Nov 2026 |
| SetupHow much experience it takes to set up. | Some experience needed | Some experience needed |
| How we checked itHands-on means a person on our team used it. | Research | Research |
| Last scoredWhen we last scored it. | Nov 2026 | Nov 2026 |
Highlighted cells are the better of the two. Scores: 7–10 4–6.9 0–3.9
We list a feature only when a source confirms it. "Not confirmed" means we haven't found one, not that the feature is missing. Some links on ChainMatch earn us a commission at no cost to you. It never changes a score: we score products before we talk to any company, using a published method. How we score recovery phrase backups.