How we score · version 1.1

How we score recovery phrase backups

CriterionWeight
Durability35%
Security20%
Ease of use20%
Compatibility10%
Value15%

A recovery phrase backup is a metal plate or capsule that stores your 12 or 24 words so they survive fire, flood and time. It never connects to anything.

Durability

  • 10: Independent tests show the words stay readable after high heat, crushing and corrosion. Stainless steel or titanium.
  • 5: Metal construction, but only the maker’s own test claims.
  • 0: Materials that melt, corrode or fade in ordinary household fires or floods.

Security

  • 10: Shows clear signs if someone opens it. No electronics, no app, no account.
  • 5: No electronics, but no tamper evidence.
  • 0: Needs an app, an account or anything online.

Ease of use

  • 10: A beginner can record a 24-word phrase correctly in under 20 minutes, with clear instructions.
  • 5: Works, but slow or easy to get letters out of order.
  • 0: Easy to record words wrongly without noticing.

Compatibility

  • 10: Holds 12- and 24-word phrases plus an optional passphrase, for any standard wallet.
  • 5: Fits standard phrases only.
  • 0: Limited to one brand’s format.

Value

  • 10: Among the lowest prices for its durability.
  • 5: Average.
  • 0: Expensive for what it offers.