How we score · version 1.1

How we score software wallets

CriterionWeight
Security design25%
Scam resistance25%
Track record20%
Ease of use15%
Coverage15%

A software wallet is an app or browser extension that holds your keys on your phone or computer. It’s convenient, and it’s where most wallet-drainer scams happen, so scam resistance carries extra weight.

Security design

  • 10: Open source with recent published audits. Keys encrypted on the device and never sent to the company. Supports connecting a hardware wallet.
  • 5: Audited but closed source, or open source with old or partial audits.
  • 0: Closed source, no audits, or keys leave the device.

Scam resistance

  • 10: Previews what a transaction will do before you sign (“simulation”), warns about known scam sites and risky approvals, and makes it easy to review and revoke past approvals.
  • 5: Some warnings, but no transaction preview.
  • 0: Signs whatever a site asks with no warnings.

Track record

  • 10: No serious incidents in five years, with quick, open disclosure and a bug bounty.
  • 5: A past incident, handled openly and fixed.
  • 0: Repeated or hidden incidents.

Ease of use

  • 10: Clear setup that makes you back up your recovery phrase, and readable prompts when you sign.
  • 5: Usable, but prompts are technical.
  • 0: Confusing enough to cause mistakes.

Coverage

  • 10: Supports the major blockchains and most popular apps, on both phone and desktop.
  • 5: A few blockchains or one platform only.
  • 0: One blockchain, limited app support.