How we score · version 1.1

How we score security keys

CriterionWeight
Security30%
Compatibility25%
Build and durability15%
Ease of setup15%
Value15%

A security key is a small device you plug in or tap to log in. It only works on the real website, so it stops fake login pages even if you type your password into one.

Security

  • 10: Certified for the FIDO2 standard, supports passkeys and has published independent security reviews.
  • 5: Supports the older U2F standard, or FIDO2 without certification.
  • 0: Not phishing-resistant, such as keys that only generate one-time codes.

Compatibility

  • 10: USB-C and NFC (tap to a phone), and works with major exchanges, email providers and password managers.
  • 5: One connection type, or limited site support.
  • 0: Works with few of the services our readers use.

Build and durability

  • 10: Waterproof, crush-resistant and has no battery.
  • 5: Sturdy, but not tested for water or crushing.
  • 0: Fragile, or needs charging.

Ease of setup

  • 10: Clear instructions for adding it to common accounts, with help for setting up a backup key.
  • 5: Works, but setup help is thin.
  • 0: Setup regularly fails or confuses buyers.

Value

  • 10: Among the lowest prices for its features, often sold in two-packs for a backup.
  • 5: Average.
  • 0: Expensive for what it offers.