How we score · version 1.0
How we score insider allocation
When a new token launches, some of it often goes to the people who built it and the investors who funded them, before anyone else can buy. A large insider allocation concentrates control over the network’s governance and its market. It says nothing about whether the technology works, but it matters for how decentralized a network can really be.
We score every network with its own token on this, out of 10.
The short version
- We take the token supply at launch and sort it into three groups: insiders, insider-controlled and public.
- Insider-controlled tokens count half.
- Score = 10 × (1 − effective insider share ÷ 80%), so 0% scores 10, 40% scores 5, and 80% or more scores 0.
- Long lockups for insiders add up to 1 point. Fair launches score 10. Allocations that were never disclosed score 1.
Step 1: what counts as “at launch”
The supply that existed or was allocated when the network or its token went live (the genesis block or token generation event), including any presale before that. Coins issued later as mining or staking rewards aren’t part of the launch supply. If some launch supply was burned or never allocated, we leave it out and say so.
Step 2: sort the supply into groups
| Group | Examples | Counts as |
|---|---|---|
| Insiders | Founders, team and employees, early contributors, advisors, seed, private and strategic investors (venture funds), market makers | 100% |
| Insider-controlled | Foundation, company treasury, “ecosystem” or “community” funds that the foundation or company decides how to spend | 50% |
| Public | Open public sales anyone could join on the same terms, airdrops to users, open mining or staking from day one | 0% |
Why half for insider-controlled tokens? They usually aren’t the insiders’ own money, but insiders decide who receives them. Counting them fully would treat a grant program like a founder’s wallet; ignoring them would miss real control.
Edge cases:
- A treasury that can only move by an on-chain token-holder vote with enforced rules counts as public. A treasury run by a foundation or multisig counts as insider-controlled.
- Node or validator sales open only to selected buyers count as insiders.
- A public sale counts as public even if insiders also bought in, unless the project’s own documents show a separate insider tranche.
Step 3: calculate
effective insider share = insiders + 0.5 × insider-controlled
base score = 10 × (1 − effective ÷ 0.80), kept between 0 and 10
Step 4: add a lockup bonus
| Insider lockups | Bonus |
|---|---|
| Four years or more, with at least a one-year wait before any sales | +1.0 |
| Two to four years | +0.5 |
| Under two years, none, or not disclosed | 0 |
Lockups don’t change who owns the tokens, so the bonus is small. The score never goes above 10.
Special cases
- Fair launch (no premine, no presale; every coin issued through open mining or staking): 10.
- Never disclosed how the launch supply was split: 1, labelled “Not disclosed”. We can’t check what we can’t see.
- No token of its own (for example a layer 2 that uses ETH for fees): doesn’t apply, and it’s left out of the Decentralization Index.
Labels
| Score | Label |
|---|---|
| 8 to 10 | Widely distributed |
| 5 to 7.9 | Moderate insider share |
| 2.5 to 4.9 | High insider share |
| 0 to 2.4 | Very high insider share |
Worked example (fictional)
Example Chain C launched with 36% for seed and private investors and 13% for the team (49% insiders), 10% for its foundation and 38% for a community reserve the foundation runs (48% insider-controlled), and 3% in a public auction.
- Effective insider share: 49% + 0.5 × 48% = 73%
- Base score: 10 × (1 − 0.73 ÷ 0.80) = 0.9
- Insider lockups of two to four years: +0.5
- Score: 1.4, “Very high insider share”
Sources and corrections
We start with the project’s own whitepaper, token documentation and launch announcements, then use regulatory filings and reputable reporting. Every network profile lists the sources for its allocation. If you represent a project and believe a figure is wrong, email us with evidence. We’ll review it, correct anything we got wrong and note the change.
See these scores in action: compare networks side by side.