How we score · version 1.1
How we score exchanges
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Licensing and regulation | 20% |
| Security and track record | 25% |
| Proof of reserves and transparency | 15% |
| Fees | 15% |
| Ease of use | 15% |
| Customer support | 10% |
An exchange is where most people buy their first crypto. While your crypto sits there, the exchange holds it for you, so our scores focus on whether it keeps your money safe. Which exchanges you can use depends on where you live.
Licensing and regulation
- 10: Licensed or registered in every major market it serves (for example US state money-transmitter licences and FinCEN registration, EU MiCA authorization, UK FCA registration), with no major unresolved enforcement actions.
- 5: Registered in some markets, or past enforcement actions that have been settled.
- 0: Operating without required licences, or serving customers where it’s banned.
Security and track record
- 10: No customer losses from hacks in five years. Supports hardware security keys for login and withdrawals, plus withdrawal address allowlists. Publishes how it stores customer funds.
- 5: A past hack, with customers fully repaid and the cause fixed.
- 0: Customer losses that weren’t repaid, or repeated hacks.
The security caps apply on top of this score.
Proof of reserves and transparency
- 10: Regular proof of reserves that includes liabilities, checked by an independent firm, or audited public financial statements.
- 5: Proof of reserves without liabilities, or published irregularly.
- 0: No evidence that it holds customers’ funds.
Fees
- 10: Low trading and withdrawal fees, shown clearly before you confirm.
- 5: Average fees, or costs hidden in the price you pay.
- 0: High or hidden fees.
Ease of use
- 10: A beginner can verify their identity, buy, and withdraw to their own wallet without outside help. Clear warnings about scams.
- 5: Works, but confusing in places.
- 0: Confusing enough to cause costly mistakes.
Customer support
- 10: Real people reachable through official channels, with clear warnings about impersonators.
- 5: Slow, ticket-only support.
- 0: Hard to reach, which pushes customers toward fake “support” scammers.